StreamSnagSample study guide. Made by StreamSnag from an invented lecture, written for this purpose and not taken from any real course. A Deep pack: the guide, its worked examples, its quiz and flashcards were written by AI (DeepSeek Flash) from the lecture's captions and slide text; the diagram was drawn by StreamSnag from the lecture's facts. The times open the sample study page, which has no video.Reading editionStudy guideCheat sheetStudy pageAll samples
LAW101 · Study guide

Offer and acceptance

Made by StreamSnag with AI from the transcript of this lecture. Every part points to the minute it comes from: check anything important against the lecture itself.

Big picture

This lecture answers how the law decides that two people have reached an agreement, focusing on offer and acceptance. It begins with the objective test, then distinguishes offers from invitations to treat using shop displays, adverts and auctions. It explains unilateral offers and the mirror image rule, then covers communication of acceptance, including silence, instant and postal rules. Finally it lists how offers end and gives a four-question method for problem questions.

After this lecture you should be able to

  • Explain the objective test for agreement and why the law uses it.
  • Distinguish an offer from an invitation to treat using examples such as shop displays, advertisements and auctions.
  • Analyse unilateral offers and explain how they are accepted, using Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.
  • Apply the mirror image rule and explain the effect of a counter-offer versus a request for information.
  • Compare the rules for communication of acceptance by instant means and by post, including exceptions.
  • Identify the four ways an offer may end and determine whether an offer was still open when accepted.

Key ideas

1

How does the law decide whether two people have agreed, and why objectively?Core

01:44 · slide 2also at01:0501:1901:5802:1302:45

The law decides whether two people have agreed by using the pair of ideas offer and acceptance, which covers almost every case you will meet this year. One side makes an offer, the other accepts it, and a contract comes into existence at the moment of acceptance, not a second before. Underneath all the rules sits the objective approach: the law does not ask what was really going on inside your head. It asks what a reasonable person, watching what you said and did, would have understood you to mean. This is because nobody can see inside anybody else's head; if you could escape a deal by saying yes but secretly meaning no, no contract would be safe. So if you behave in a way that would lead a reasonable person to think you were agreeing, and the other side relies on that, you are held to it. Smith v Hughes (1871) is the case usually given for this.

In the lecturer's words“It asks what a reasonable person, watching what you said and did, would have understood you to mean”
Example

Smith v Hughes in 1871 is the case usually given for judging agreement objectively. The reason is that nobody can see inside anybody else's head; if I could get out of a deal by saying I said yes but secretly meant no, no contract would be safe.

Ask yourself

Why does the law judge agreement by what a reasonable person would understand rather than by what you secretly intended, and how does that protect the other side?

2

When is a statement or display an offer rather than an invitation to treat?Core

03:41 · slide 3also at05:0605:1505:3105:4306:19

A statement is an offer when all the other side has to do is say yes and a contract is made; if it is just an opening move, it is an invitation to treat, which is an invitation to make an offer and not a promise to deal with anyone who turns up. Goods displayed on a shelf in a shop are only an invitation to treat (Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots, 1953): the customer makes the offer at the till and the shop accepts it there, under the pharmacist's eye, so the sale takes place under supervision. If the display were the offer, picking a box up would be acceptance, so you could not change your mind and put it back, and the shop could not refuse to sell to you. Treating the display as an invitation keeps both sides free until the till. Goods in a shop window with a price ticket are likewise an invitation to treat, not an offer (Fisher v Bell, 1961), and the general rule is that an advertisement is an invitation to treat as well (Partridge v Crittenden, 1968).

In the lecturer's words“An invitation to treat is an invitation to make an offer. It is an opening move”
Example

In Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots (1953) the Court of Appeal held the display on the shelf was only an invitation to treat; the customer makes the offer at the till and the shop accepts it there, under the pharmacist's eye. In Fisher v Bell (1961) a flick knife in a shop window with a price ticket was an invitation to treat, not an offer.

Ask yourself

Why does treating a shop display as an invitation to treat rather than an offer keep both the customer and the shop free until the till?

3

How can an advertisement be a unilateral offer, and how is it accepted?Core

09:23 · slide 5also at08:1808:3908:5409:5110:11

An advertisement can be an offer, and Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893) is the most famous contract case about an advert that was an offer. The company advertised it would pay one hundred pounds to anyone who used the smoke ball three times a day for two weeks as directed and still caught influenza, and said it had deposited a thousand pounds with its bank to show it was serious. Mrs Carlill did as directed, caught influenza, and asked for her hundred pounds. The Court of Appeal held the advert was an offer made to the whole world, which anyone could accept by doing what it asked. The court answered the company's argument that it was a mere sales puff by pointing to the thousand-pound deposit, which a reasonable reader would take seriously. It also held that an offer can be made to the whole world and is accepted by whoever does the thing asked, and that in an offer of this kind the offeror has, by its own words, done away with the need to be told. Doing what was asked is the acceptance; such an offer is called a unilateral offer, where only one side makes a promise and the other just performs.

In the lecturer's words“It held that this advert was an offer, made to the whole world, which anyone could accept by doing what it asked”
Example

The smoke ball company advertised it would pay one hundred pounds to anyone who used the ball three times a day for two weeks as directed and still caught influenza, and said it had deposited a thousand pounds with its bank for the purpose. Mrs Carlill used it as directed, caught influenza, and the Court of Appeal held the advert was an offer to the whole world accepted by doing what it asked.

Ask yourself

How does the thousand-pound deposit help explain why the smoke ball advertisement was an offer rather than a mere sales puff?

4

What does acceptance have to do to the offer, and what kills the offer?Core

12:11 · slide 6also at12:3912:5813:1813:51

Acceptance has to match the offer exactly, which people call the mirror image rule: the acceptance is a mirror of the offer, a yes on exactly those terms. If you reply with different terms, that is not an acceptance at all but a counter-offer, which is a new offer the other side can accept or reject, and it kills the original offer so you cannot go back to it. In Hyde v Wrench (1840) Wrench offered to sell his farm to Hyde for a thousand pounds; Hyde replied offering nine hundred and fifty, and Wrench said no. When Hyde then wrote that he accepted the thousand, the court held there was no contract: the offer of a thousand had died when Hyde made his counter-offer, leaving nothing to accept. But not every reply that is not a plain yes is a counter-offer: in Stevenson v McLean (1880) the buyer's reply asking whether he could take delivery over a few months was held to be only a request for information, so the offer remained open.

In the lecturer's words“acceptance has to match the offer exactly. People call this the mirror image rule”
Example

In Hyde v Wrench (1840) Wrench offered to sell his farm for a thousand pounds; Hyde replied offering nine hundred and fifty. After Wrench said no, Hyde wrote that he accepted the thousand, but the court held there was no contract because the offer of a thousand had died when Hyde made his counter-offer.

Ask yourself

Why does a counter-offer kill the original offer, and how was the reply in Stevenson v McLean different?

Worked example

Working an advertisement problem: general rule then Carlill

A company advertises that it will pay a reward to anyone who does the act it asks, and backs this by saying it has put a thousand pounds in the bank to support the promise. A reader does the act asked, then the company argues the advert was only a sales puff and that it was never told of any acceptance. Is the advert an offer and was it accepted?

  1. Apply the general rule first: an advertisement is an invitation to treat. That is only the starting point, since Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893) is the most famous case of an advert that was an offer.08:18 · slide 4
  2. Ask whether this advert is like Carlill: is it clear and definite, does it ask for an act rather than a reply, and is there anything, like the deposit, that shows it was meant seriously? Here the stated thousand pounds in the bank is exactly such a thing.09:51 · slide 5
  3. Answer the sales puff argument by looking at the deposit: the advertiser told people it had put a thousand pounds in the bank to back the promise, so a reasonable reader would take it seriously.09:51 · slide 5
  4. Treat the offer as one made to the whole world, accepted by whoever does the thing asked. This is a unilateral offer: only one side promises, the other just performs.10:23 · slide 5
  5. Answer the complaint that no acceptance was communicated: in an offer of this kind the offeror has, by its own words, done away with the need to be told, so doing what was asked is the acceptance.10:23 · slide 5

Result. The advert is an offer, and the reader's performance of the act asked is the acceptance, so the company is bound.

Worked example

Applying Hyde v Wrench to a counter-offer

Wrench offered to sell his farm to Hyde for a thousand pounds. Hyde replied offering nine hundred and fifty. Wrench said no. Hyde then wrote, fine, I accept the thousand. Is there a contract?

  1. Check whether the reply mirrors the offer. Hyde's reply of nine hundred and fifty is not an acceptance but a counter-offer, a new offer Wrench can accept or reject.12:39 · slide 6
  2. Apply the second effect of a counter-offer: it kills the original offer, so the thousand-pound offer cannot be gone back to.12:39 · slide 6
  3. Note Wrench said no to the counter-offer, so the new offer was not accepted either.12:58 · slide 6
  4. Hyde's later letter accepting the thousand comes too late: the offer of a thousand had died when Hyde made his counter-offer, and there was nothing left for him to accept.13:18 · slide 6

Result. There is no contract: the original thousand-pound offer was killed by the counter-offer, and Hyde's later acceptance had nothing to fasten on.

Comparison · drawn by StreamSnag from the lecture's facts

Ordinary bilateral contract and unilateral offer

Comparison: Ordinary bilateral contract and unilateral offer2 things compared on 2 points. The same relations are written out in words under the diagram.bilateralcontractunilateralofferpromisespromises onboth sidesonly one sidemakes apromiseacceptanceone promisesto sell, otherto paydoing what wasasked
The diagram in words
bilateral contractunilateral offer
promises 10:43 · slide 5promises on both sidesonly one side makes a promise
acceptance 10:33 · slide 5one promises to sell, other to paydoing what was asked
5

When is acceptance communicated, and when is silence or post enough?Core

15:15 · slide 7also at15:3116:2516:3817:3317:48

An acceptance generally has to be communicated; it is not enough to decide privately that you accept, and silence is not acceptance (Felthouse v Bindley, 1862). You cannot make somebody's silence into a yes just by saying so in your offer, because nobody should be able to force a contract on you by writing that if you do not reply you have agreed. With instant ways of talking, face to face or by telephone, acceptance counts when it is communicated. But there is one big exception: the postal rule. Where it is reasonable to accept by post, acceptance is complete as soon as the letter is posted, not when it arrives (Adams v Lindsell, 1818). That means the contract can exist even if the letter is delayed, or even if it is lost and never arrives, which is what happened in Household Fire Insurance v Grant (1879). The postal rule is excluded if the offer requires actual receipt of the acceptance in writing, as in Holwell Securities v Hughes (1974).

In the lecturer's words“An acceptance generally has to be communicated. It is not enough to decide, privately, that you accept.”
Example

In Felthouse v Bindley (1862), an uncle negotiating to buy his nephew's horse wrote that if he heard nothing more he would consider the horse his, but the court held silence is not acceptance. Under the postal rule from Adams v Lindsell (1818) a contract can exist even if the letter is lost and never arrives, as in Household Fire Insurance v Grant (1879).

Ask yourself

Why does the postal rule put the risk of a lost letter on the person who made the offer, and how can that person avoid the rule?

Review sheets

Unilateral offers and the Carlill case

Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893) is the classic case where an advertisement was held to be an offer made to the whole world, accepted by anyone who performed the stated act. The rest of the lecture needs it because it shows the exception to the general rule that advertisements are invitations to treat, and it introduces the unilateral offer and the idea that acceptance need not be communicated when the offeror has done away with the need to be told.

Step by step

  1. The starting point is that an advertisement is usually an invitation to treat, but the most famous contract case of all is about an advertisement that was an offer: Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company, 1893. 08:18
  2. The company sold a smoke ball to sniff to prevent influenza and advertised that it would pay one hundred pounds to anyone who used the ball three times a day for two weeks as directed and still caught influenza. The advert also said the company had deposited a thousand pounds with its bank to show it was serious. 08:39
  3. Mrs Carlill bought one, used it as directed, caught influenza, and asked for her hundred pounds. The company replied in effect that it had never made a promise and that it was only an advertisement. 08:39
  4. The Court of Appeal disagreed and held that the advert was an offer made to the whole world, which anyone could accept by doing what it asked. 09:23
  5. The company argued the advert was a mere sales puff not meant seriously, but the court pointed to the thousand-pound deposit: a reasonable reader would take that seriously. 09:51
  6. The company argued you cannot make an offer to the whole world, but the court said you can, and it is accepted by whoever does the thing asked. The company also argued Mrs Carlill never told it she was accepting, but the court said that in an offer of this kind the offeror has, by its own words, done away with the need to be told. 10:11
  7. So doing what was asked is the acceptance, and an offer like that is called a unilateral offer. Only one side makes a promise (if you do this, I will pay you); the other side promises nothing and just performs. Rewards for lost pets are the everyday example. 10:33
  8. This contrasts with the ordinary bilateral contract, where there are promises on both sides: one promises to sell, the other promises to pay. 11:01
  9. In exam problem questions on advertisements, writing simply that adverts are invitations to treat and stopping there will lose marks. The right answer works through the general rule and then asks whether this advert is like Carlill: is it clear and definite, does it ask for an act rather than a reply, and is there anything like the deposit that shows seriousness. 11:23

How it connects

This topic connects to the lecture's other key idea on when an advertisement can be a unilateral offer and how it is accepted: Carlill shows an advert can be an offer to the whole world, accepted by performing the act. It also links to the idea that acceptance need not be communicated when the offeror has done away with the need to be told, which is part of the lecture's treatment of when acceptance is communicated.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeThinking that all advertisements are invitations to treat and stopping there.InsteadThe general rule is only a starting point; an advert can be an offer, as in Carlill, if it is clear and definite and asks for an act.
  • MistakeThinking a unilateral offer cannot be made to the whole world.InsteadThe court held you can make an offer to the whole world, accepted by whoever does the thing asked.
  • MistakeThinking acceptance must always be communicated to the offeror.InsteadIn a unilateral offer the offeror has, by its own words, done away with the need to be told; doing what was asked is the acceptance.
  • MistakeConfusing unilateral and bilateral contracts.InsteadIn a unilateral offer only one side makes a promise; in a bilateral contract there are promises on both sides.

Go back to

The postal rule and its limits

The postal rule is an exception to the general requirement that acceptance be communicated: where it is reasonable to accept by post, acceptance is complete as soon as the letter is posted, not when it arrives. The rest of the lecture needs it because it qualifies when acceptance is communicated and contrasts with the general rule that silence is not acceptance and that revocation must actually reach the other side.

Step by step

  1. Start from the general requirement: an acceptance generally has to be communicated, and privately deciding to accept is not enough. The offeror has to be told. 15:15
  2. The flip side is that silence is not acceptance, as held in Felthouse v Bindley (1862). Nobody can force a contract on you by writing that if you do not reply you have agreed. 15:31
  3. That general rule applies where acceptance must be communicated. But there is one big exception: the postal rule. 15:15
  4. Where it is reasonable to accept by post, acceptance is complete as soon as the letter is posted, not when it arrives. That comes from Adams v Lindsell (1818). 17:33
  5. Under the postal rule the contract can exist even if the acceptance letter is delayed or lost and never arrives, as in Household Fire Insurance v Grant (1879). Someone must carry the risk of the post, and the courts put it on the offeror, who chose to start the deal in a way that invited a reply by post. 17:48
  6. But the offeror can protect themselves: if the offer says, I must actually receive your acceptance in writing, then the postal rule does not apply. That was Holwell Securities v Hughes (1974). 18:30
  7. The postal rule does not help the offeror's revocation. In Byrne v Van Tienhoven (1880), a revocation counts only when it actually reaches the other side; by then the offer had been accepted, so there was a contract. 21:02

How it connects

The postal rule qualifies the lecture's key idea of when acceptance is communicated, and it is contrasted with the rule that silence is not acceptance and with the rule that revocation must actually reach the other side. It also shows the offeror can control the mode of acceptance by requiring actual receipt.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeThinking that privately deciding to accept is enough.InsteadAn acceptance generally has to be communicated; the offeror has to be told.
  • MistakeThinking an offeror can turn silence into acceptance by saying so.InsteadYou cannot make somebody's silence into a yes just by saying so in your offer.
  • MistakeThinking acceptance by post is complete when the letter arrives.InsteadWhere it is reasonable to accept by post, acceptance is complete as soon as the letter is posted.
  • MistakeThinking the postal rule applies even when the offer requires actual receipt.InsteadIf the offer says the acceptance must actually be received in writing, the postal rule does not apply.

Go back to

Easily confused

offerinvitation to treat
What it isofferA promise to deal on terms all set; saying yes makes a contract.invitation to treatAn invitation to make an offer; an opening move saying come and talk.
Shop display treated asofferWould make picking a box up acceptance, binding the customer.invitation to treatLeaves the customer free to put the box back and the shop free to refuse.
counter-offerrequest for information
Effect on original offercounter-offerKills the original offer, so it cannot be accepted later.request for informationDoes not reject anything; the offer remains open to be accepted.
What it iscounter-offerA new offer the other side can accept or reject.request for informationOnly asking; not a reply that turns the offer down.

Self-test

Answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper, before you open the answer. Then mark yourself honestly.

  1. Explain

    Why does contract law judge agreement objectively rather than by asking what each party secretly intended?

    Show answer

    Because nobody can see inside another's head, the law asks what a reasonable person watching the parties' words and conduct would understand. If a party could escape a deal by secretly meaning 'no' while saying 'yes', no contract would be safe. This is the approach associated with Smith v Hughes (1871).

    A good answer includes
    • reasonable person watching words and conduct
    • no one can see inside another's head
    • otherwise no contract would be safe

    Review this part01:44 · slide 2

    How did you do?
  2. Apply

    A shopper in a self-service store takes a bottle of cough syrup from a shelf, changes her mind, and puts it back. Has a contract already been formed? Explain using Boots.

    Show answer

    No. The display on the shelf is only an invitation to treat, not an offer (Pharmaceutical Society v Boots). The customer makes the offer at the till and the shop accepts it there, so putting the bottle back before the till means no contract has been made.

    A good answer includes
    • shelf display is invitation to treat
    • customer makes offer at till
    • shop accepts at till
    • no contract before till

    Review this part05:06 · slide 4

    How did you do?
  3. Go further

    Suppose a shop window display were legally an offer rather than an invitation to treat. What would follow for a customer who picks up the goods, and for the shop? Use Fisher v Bell and Boots reasoning.

    Show answer

    If the display were an offer, picking the goods up would be acceptance, so a contract would form there and the customer could not change their mind and put the item back. The shop would also be unable to refuse to sell. Treating the display as an invitation to treat keeps both sides free until the till.

    A good answer includes
    • picking up would be acceptance
    • customer could not put it back
    • shop could not refuse to sell
    • both sides free until till

    Review this part05:31 · slide 4

    How did you do?
  4. Explain

    What distinguishes a unilateral offer from an ordinary bilateral contract, and how is a unilateral offer accepted?

    Show answer

    In a bilateral contract both sides make promises (e.g., I promise to sell, you promise to pay). In a unilateral offer only one side makes a promise (if you do this, I will pay you); the other side promises nothing and just performs. Doing what was asked is the acceptance, and the offeror has by its own words dispensed with the need to be told of acceptance.

    A good answer includes
    • bilateral: promises on both sides
    • unilateral: only one side promises
    • other side just performs
    • acceptance by doing the act

    Review this part10:23 · slide 5

    How did you do?
  5. Apply

    A company advertises: 'We will pay £500 to anyone who runs the town marathon in our shirt and finishes.' It adds that £10,000 is deposited with its bank to show sincerity. A runner does so. Is there a contract, and why does the deposit matter?

    Show answer

    Yes. The advertisement is an offer to the whole world, accepted by anyone who does the thing asked, as in Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. The stated deposit shows a reasonable reader would take the promise seriously, so it is not a mere sales puff. The offeror has by its own words removed the need to be told of acceptance.

    A good answer includes
    • offer to the whole world
    • accepted by doing the act
    • deposit shows serious intent
    • not a mere puff

    Review this part09:23 · slide 5

    How did you do?
  6. Apply

    Seller offers to sell a car for £8,000. Buyer replies: 'I will give you £7,500.' Seller refuses. Buyer then says: 'Fine, I accept your £8,000 offer.' Is there a contract? Use Hyde v Wrench.

    Show answer

    No. The buyer's £7,500 reply was a counter-offer, which is a new offer and kills the original £8,000 offer. When the buyer later purports to accept £8,000 there is nothing left to accept, as in Hyde v Wrench. A mere request for information (as in Stevenson v McLean) would have been different, but this was a counter-offer.

    A good answer includes
    • £7,500 reply is a counter-offer
    • counter-offer kills original offer
    • nothing left to accept
    • Hyde v Wrench

    Review this part12:39 · slide 6

    How did you do?
  7. Explain

    Why is silence not treated as acceptance, and what does Felthouse v Bindley decide about an offeror who writes that non-reply will count as agreement?

    Show answer

    Acceptance generally has to be communicated; privately deciding to accept is not enough. An offeror cannot turn an offeree's silence into a yes merely by saying so in the offer, because nobody should be able to force a contract on you by writing that your non-reply counts as agreement. In Felthouse v Bindley the nephew never communicated acceptance, so the horse was not the uncle's.

    A good answer includes
    • acceptance must be communicated
    • silence not acceptance
    • cannot impose silence as acceptance
    • nephew never communicated

    Review this part15:15 · slide 7

    How did you do?
  8. Apply

    On Monday Offeror posts an offer to Offeree and says acceptance by post is fine. On Tuesday Offeree posts an acceptance. On Wednesday Offeror posts a revocation, which reaches Offeree on Friday. When, if at all, is a contract formed?

    Show answer

    The contract is formed on Tuesday when the acceptance is posted, because where it is reasonable to accept by post the acceptance is complete on posting, not on arrival. The revocation posted on Wednesday comes too late; a revocation only works once communicated, and here it reached the offeree on Friday, after acceptance. The postal rule helps the offeree, not the offeror.

    A good answer includes
    • contract on Tuesday when posted
    • postal rule: complete on posting
    • revocation too late
    • revocation effective only when communicated

    Review this part17:33 · slide 7

    How did you do?
  9. Go further

    An offer states: 'I must actually receive your acceptance in writing at my office.' The offeree posts an acceptance that is lost and never arrives. Does the postal rule save the acceptance? Use Holwell Securities v Hughes and Household Fire v Grant.

    Show answer

    No. The postal rule is excluded where the offer requires actual receipt of the acceptance in writing, as in Holwell Securities v Hughes. Although under Household Fire v Grant the postal rule would normally make a contract even if the letter is lost, that rule applies only where it is reasonable to accept by post and is not excluded. Here the offer's terms displace it, so no contract is formed.

    A good answer includes
    • postal rule excluded by actual receipt requirement
    • Holwell Securities v Hughes
    • normally lost letter still binds under Household Fire
    • but offer's terms displace the rule

    Review this part17:48 · slide 7

    How did you do?
  10. Explain

    What are the four ways an offer can end, and what happens if an offer gives no time for acceptance?

    Show answer

    An offer can end by revocation, rejection, lapse of time, and death of a party. If the offer specifies a time, it lapses then; if it gives no time, it lapses after a reasonable time.

    A good answer includes
    • revocation
    • rejection
    • lapse of time
    • death of a party
    • reasonable time if no time given

    Review this part19:36 · slide 8

    How did you do?

Practice quiz

New cases to try the lecture's ideas on. Pick an answer to see why each option is right or wrong.

  1. Apply

    A shop puts a camera in its window with a £300 price ticket. A customer walks in and says, 'I accept your offer of the camera at £300.' What is the legal position under Fisher v Bell?

    Show answer
    • AConfuses an invitation to treat with an offer; Fisher v Bell says a window display is not an offer.
    • BCorrect. A window display with a price ticket is an invitation to treat, so the customer makes the offer.
    • CThere was no offer to kill; the mistake is treating an invitation to treat as an offer.
    • DReverses the roles: the shop's display is not an offer accepted by display.

    Review this part03:41 · slide 3

  2. Apply

    An offeror writes: 'If you do not reply by Friday, I will treat your silence as acceptance.' The offeree says nothing and does nothing by Friday. What is the result under Felthouse v Bindley?

    Show answer
    • AThe very argument rejected in Felthouse v Bindley: silence cannot be imposed as acceptance.
    • BCorrect. Silence is not acceptance, and the offeror cannot force a contract by saying so.
    • CMisuses the objective test; a reasonable person would not read silence as a yes where the law forbids it.
    • DConfuses silence with lapse of time; the reason is that silence never was acceptance.

    Review this part15:31 · slide 7

  3. Apply

    At an auction, a bidder raises a hand at £100, then shakes his head before the auctioneer brings the hammer down. What is the position under the lecture's account of auctions?

    Show answer
    • AReverses the roles: each bid is an offer, not an acceptance.
    • BCorrect. Bids are offers, and the auctioneer accepts by bringing the hammer down.
    • CInvents a writing requirement; acceptance at auction is by the fall of the hammer.
    • DConfuses a bid (offer) with a counter-offer, and wrongly makes it irrevocable.

    Review this part07:33 · slide 4

  4. Go further

    Dodds offers to sell his house to Dickinson and promises to keep the offer open until Friday. On Wednesday, a reliable third person tells Dickinson that Dodds has sold the house to someone else. On Thursday Dickinson purports to accept. What follows from Dickinson v Dodds?

    Show answer
    • AIgnores that an offeror may revoke even after promising to keep the offer open, absent payment.
    • BCorrect. A reliable third person's communication ends the offer; acceptance afterwards is too late.
    • CWrongly requires personal revocation; a reliable third person's notice suffices.
    • DConfuses communication by the offeror with communication from a reliable third person, which is enough.

    Review this part20:12 · slide 8

Check this

Not from the lecture

The boxes marked “Beyond the lecture (not from your lecturer)” were added by the AI to help. Your lecturer did not say what is in them. They are under:

  • Key idea 1: How does the law decide whether two people have agreed, and why objectively?
  • Key idea 2: When is a statement or display an offer rather than an invitation to treat?
  • Key idea 3: How can an advertisement be a unilateral offer, and how is it accepted?
  • Key idea 4: What does acceptance have to do to the offer, and what kills the offer?
  • Key idea 5: When is acceptance communicated, and when is silence or post enough?

Glossary

bilateral contract 11:01 · slide 5
An ordinary bilateral contract has promises on both sides: one promises to sell and the other promises to pay.
counter-offer 12:39 · slide 6
A counter-offer is a new offer the other side can accept or reject, and it kills the original offer so that it cannot be accepted later.
invitation to treat 03:41 · slide 3
An invitation to treat is an invitation to make an offer, an opening move rather than a promise to deal with anyone who turns up.
lapse 19:54 · slide 8
An offer lapses at the time it specifies, or after a reasonable time if it gives no time.
mirror image rule 12:11 · slide 6
Acceptance has to match the offer exactly; this is called the mirror image rule.
objective test 01:44 · slide 2
The law judges agreement objectively, asking what a reasonable person watching what you said and did would have understood you to mean.
postal rule 17:33 · slide 7
Where it is reasonable to accept by post, acceptance is complete as soon as the letter is posted, not when it arrives (postal rule).
revocation 20:26 · slide 8
A revocation of an offer takes effect only once it is communicated to the other side.
unilateral offer 10:33 · slide 5
Doing what was asked is the acceptance, and an offer of that kind is called a unilateral offer.

Flashcards

19 cards from this lecture are in your flashcard file and in StreamSnag's review. Each one shows the minute it comes from.

  1. Fill the gapTiming of a contract: a contract comes into existence at the moment of acceptance. 01:19 · slide 1
  2. QuestionAgreement: how does the law judge whether two people have agreed?

    Objectively, as a reasonable person would understand it

    01:44 · slide 2
  3. QuestionObjective agreement: why does the law judge agreement by outward words and conduct rather than inner intention?

    Because a secret meaning could make no contract safe

    02:13 · slide 2
  4. QuestionProblem questions: what question does almost every problem come back to?

    How the situation would look to a reasonable person outside

    02:45 · slide 2
  5. QuestionInvitation to treat: what does an invitation to treat invite the other party to do?

    Make an offer

    03:41 · slide 3
  6. QuestionCarlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893): what type of contract case is it known as?

    The most famous contract case of all

    08:18 · slide 4
  7. QuestionSmoke ball advertisement: to whom did the Court of Appeal hold the offer was made?

    To the whole world

    09:23 · slide 5
  8. QuestionUnilateral offer: what counts as the acceptance of an offer of that kind?

    Doing what was asked

    10:33 · slide 5
  9. QuestionUnilateral offer: how many sides make a promise in a unilateral offer?

    Only one side makes a promise

    10:43 · slide 5
  10. QuestionExam problem questions on adverts: what is wrong with simply writing that adverts are invitations to treat and stopping there?

    It will lose marks

    11:23 · slide 5
  11. QuestionMirror image rule: what must an acceptance do to the offer?

    Match the offer exactly

    12:11 · slide 6
  12. QuestionCounter-offer: what effect does it have on the original offer?

    It kills the original offer

    12:39 · slide 6
  13. QuestionHyde v Wrench: why did the court hold there was no contract?

    Hyde's counter-offer killed the thousand-pound offer

    13:18 · slide 6
  14. QuestionAcceptance: what must generally happen for a private decision to accept to count?

    It must be communicated

    15:15 · slide 7
  15. Fill the gapFelthouse v Bindley (1862): the case holds that silence is not acceptance. 15:31 · slide 7
  16. Fill the gapPostal rule: where accepting by post is reasonable, acceptance is complete as soon as the letter is posted. 17:33 · slide 7
  17. Fill the gapAn offer can end in four ways: revocation, rejection, lapse of time, and death of a party. 19:36 · slide 8
  18. Fill the gapLapse of time: an offer ends at the time it specifies, or after a reasonable time if it gives none. 19:54 · slide 8
  19. QuestionProblem question on contract formation: what is the first question to ask?

    Whether there was an offer or an invitation to treat

    22:11 · slide 9