How does the law decide whether two people have agreed, and why objectively?Core
01:44 · slide 2also at01:0501:1901:5802:1302:45
The law decides whether two people have agreed by using the pair of ideas offer and acceptance, which covers almost every case you will meet this year. One side makes an offer, the other accepts it, and a contract comes into existence at the moment of acceptance, not a second before. Underneath all the rules sits the objective approach: the law does not ask what was really going on inside your head. It asks what a reasonable person, watching what you said and did, would have understood you to mean. This is because nobody can see inside anybody else's head; if you could escape a deal by saying yes but secretly meaning no, no contract would be safe. So if you behave in a way that would lead a reasonable person to think you were agreeing, and the other side relies on that, you are held to it. Smith v Hughes (1871) is the case usually given for this.
In the lecturer's words“It asks what a reasonable person, watching what you said and did, would have understood you to mean”
Smith v Hughes in 1871 is the case usually given for judging agreement objectively. The reason is that nobody can see inside anybody else's head; if I could get out of a deal by saying I said yes but secretly meant no, no contract would be safe.
Why does the law judge agreement by what a reasonable person would understand rather than by what you secretly intended, and how does that protect the other side?